150-year-old Bible returned to descendant of original owner
In early February, James Gentry, the owner of Gentry Sales on West Davie Street in Anna, contacted local historian Dr. Susan A. Whitemountain to let her know he had acquired some old barrister book shelves that he thought she might be able to use.
Whitemountain, who operates a genealogy and family research business called The Gathering Place on South Main Street, was interested and went to Gentry’s to have a look.
The old bookshelves were among several things Gentry had acquired from one of the storage lockers he had recently purchased in Illinois and Kentucky. Also found among the items was a plastic bin filled with old Bibles.
James’ mother, Karen Gentry, found the 150-year-old Bible among the lot and set it aside.
“I won’t sell a Bible,” she told Whitemountain. “I would like you to see if you can find any descendants and return the Bible to them.”
Whitemountain brought the Bible back to her shop and began to search for a descendant of the Bible’s original owner.
Inside the front cover of the Bible was inscribed the name Charles Lee, along with the date March 8, 1869.
A page at the center of the Bible documented the marriage of Charles Lee to Mariah Bliss on March 24, 1864, in Hardin County, and the births, marriages and deaths of their children Melissa (1865-1866), Melvina (Charles Gerhardt) (1867-1937), Amanda (William Thompson) (1870-1954), Charles R. Jr. (Anne Martin) (1872-1956), John D. (1874-1960) and Clara (1886-1887).
This information was used by Whitemountain to create an historical lineage for the Lee family that connected them to Hardin and Pope counties in Illinois.
Who was Charles Lee?
Charles Lee was born on Feb. 3, 1839, in what is now Hardin County, Illinois.
Charles’ father, William Lee, was born there in 1812, when the area was still a part of Pope County in the Illinois Territory.
His mother, Amanda Cassatt, was born in Kentucky in 1817 and migrated to Pope County with her family when young.
The original families farmed, and descending family names are still found in Hardin County near Elizabethtown and Rosiclare, where the original pioneers had settled.
Charles Lee enlisted on July 29, 1861, at Elizabethtown, Illinois, as a private in Company A of the 29th Illinois Infantry and was mustered into service for three years at Camp Butler on Aug. 19 of the same year.
Company A was filled with men from Hardin County.
Lee’s muster report documents that he was 22 years old at the time, single, 5 feet, 9 1/2 inches tall, and had black hair, hazel eyes, and a dark complexion.
His given occupation was farmer. Lee was appointed full corporal on Oct. 1, 1861.
Corporals were the men in a regiment who carried the flag into battle, and when not carrying the flag themselves they guarded the man given that task.
If the flag bearer was injured or killed, another corporal would pick up the flag and keep moving it forward.
During battle there was a lot of smoke on the battle field and the regimental flag was often the only way troops could locate and follow their regimental line.
Lee reenlisted as a veteran for three years on Jan. 1, 1864, at Natchez, Mississippi, and was mustered in on Feb. 27.
Muster reports show that Lee was promoted to full second lieutenant on Nov. 5, 1865, but mustered out on Nov. 6 as a corporal at Hempstead, Texas.
Finding Descendants of Charles Lee
On Feb. 11, the Daniel Chapman Chapter of the Daughters of the American Revolution, DAR, met at The Gathering Place.
Whitemountain shared the contents of the Bible with Jeanne Boglino, a DAR sister who lives in Pope County.
Boglino took copious notes about the contents inscribed in the Bible and commented that many of the surnames listed were familiar names to her from Pope County.
She shared with Whitemountain that she didn’t know if she would be able to find anything but would try.
Boglino’s sister, Alice Thodoropoulos, also a member of the Daniel Chapman Chapter, shared that her sister at first questioned: “Why did I ever volunteer for such a project?”
But then Boglino really got into it and spent a lot of time on the project.
Boglino shared the following with Whitemountain:
“After searching through a number of death/marriage certificates in our courthouse that were listed in the Bible I finally found one I could connect to - haha - LAST one on the list of course!
“I knew the Gerhardt name rang a bell, but I couldn’t place it and lo and behold it showed up in the death certificates connecting it to someone I knew!
“I have talked with the wife whose husband is the grandson of a Clarence Gerhardt.
“I explained briefly my ‘mission’ and told her you had a Bible. I asked if I could share she and her husband’s phone number with you which she gladly gave me - I told her I thought you would contact them.
“Their names are C.L. (Clarence but he goes by C.L.) and Earnestine Evitts.
“The info I copied from the Bible was C.W. Gerhardt (Gayharted) in the Bible.
“The initials in the Bible were CW - the name on the death certificate was only Clarence Gerhardt - the son-in-law - C.L.
“Evitts signed the death certificate and his wife was Pauline Gerhardt- daughter of Clarence - she is deceased also - and her husband is in a nursing home - father of the man I have given you the address for.
“Are you totally confused now LOL - hope not! I feel like there should be a connection with Gerhardt being the key here. After talking to C.L. hopefully things will be more clear.”
Based on what Boglino had found, Whitemountain was able to confirm that C.L. Evitts was in fact the great-great-grandson of Charles Lee, the original owner of the Bible.
Whitemountain contacted the Evitts to give them the news.
C.L. and Earnestine Evitts came to Anna from their home near Simpson in Johnson County on Monday, March 25, and took possession of the Bible and the Lee family history that had been compiled by Whitemountain.
C. L. shared with Whitemountain: “We are very pleased to have the Bible and look forward to sharing it with our children and other extended family.”
C.L. Evitts is now the chosen storyteller for his Lee family history.
(Editor’s note: the accompanying story and photographs were shared by Susan Whitemountain.)


